America's #1 Tribute To Foreigner
2025/2026
Perry (owner of Northwoods Inn Amphitheater) - Wisconsin
Mary (Executive Director- Schauer Arts Center) Hartford, Wisconsin
Dusty (Manager - St. Croix Casino) Turtle Lake, Wisconsin
Dusty (Manager - St. Croix Casino) Turtle Lake, Wisconsin
Mary (Executive Director- Schauer Arts Center) Hartford, Wisconsin
Mitch (DJ at 102.9 The Hog) Milwaukee, WI
Here's a fun video clip of several songs we perform! Note: no audio on this one.
Feels Like The First Time is an American 7-piece rock band formed in 2017 as a tribute to the music of British/American rock band Foreigner and is based out of Milwaukee, WI. The band is made up of veteran musicians with decades of experience entertaining rock music fans at premier venues, festivals and concert events. The members of Fee
Feels Like The First Time is an American 7-piece rock band formed in 2017 as a tribute to the music of British/American rock band Foreigner and is based out of Milwaukee, WI. The band is made up of veteran musicians with decades of experience entertaining rock music fans at premier venues, festivals and concert events. The members of Feels Like The First Time, having grown up with the music of Foreigner, are proud to perform for you, as they pay tribute to the music of Foreigner!
The band has performed throughout the midwest at festivals and venues and its members have over 200 years of combined performance experience, which includes opening slots for Night Ranger, Blue Oyster Cult, and Head East.
Donald Fagan (vocals/percussion) - There are many vocalists/artists who struggle to establish their musical identity. There are also others that emerge fully formed, in full command of their craft. Donald Fagan fits firmly in the latter category. A Wisconsin native, Donald played trumpet and guitar. He also sang in choirs in High School
Donald Fagan (vocals/percussion) - There are many vocalists/artists who struggle to establish their musical identity. There are also others that emerge fully formed, in full command of their craft. Donald Fagan fits firmly in the latter category. A Wisconsin native, Donald played trumpet and guitar. He also sang in choirs in High School and church. He began to take formal vocal lessons in his early 20’s, which he did for several years. He has performed in several bands throughout the 80’s and 90’s. Today, as the front man for F4E, he’s taken his vocal talent and his ability to engage with the audience, to a whole new level.
Thomas Hunter (guitar/keyboards) - Born in Brooklyn, NY, Tom Hunter acquired his first guitar in 1979. The drums were Tom’s first passion, but ultimately it was the guitar that, as Tom puts it, “chose me, not the other way around”. Tom cites his main influences as Joe Perry, Dickie Betts, Eric Clapton and Albert King. Tom primarily plays Gibson guitars and prefers Fender Amps. When not performing on stage with Foreigner 4 Ever, Tom writes and records his own original music in his home studio in Racine, WI.
Chris Boyden (guitar/vocals) -
Matt Bishop (keyboards/vocals) -
Randy Paul Jones (bass guitar/vocals) -
Greg Hoernke (drums) -
Dan Keilman (saxophone/flute/percussion/vocals) -
Feels Like The First Time celebrates the music of FOREIGNER, the band behind “I Want To Know What Love Is,” “Cold As Ice,” “Juke Box Hero,” and so many others of rock’s most enduring anthems, and is looking forward to providing their professional, authentic shows for 2025! America's Foreigner tribute act will heat up the "cold as ice" days & nights with a series of “hot blooded” songs!
Please let us know if you'll be attending one of our shows! We'd love to meet you!
Subscribe to our email, and win a chance for free tickets to one of our shows!